Bugs That Look Like Praying Mantis: How to Tell Them Apart

Bugs That Look Like Praying Mantis: How to Tell Them Apart

Bugs that look like praying mantis are most often mantidflies, thread-legged bugs, ambush bugs, katydids, walking sticks or wheel bugs. Many unrelated insects evolved grasping front legs or stick-thin bodies, so a mantis-shaped bug on a porch or flower can be something else. A wheel bug can bite, a katydid chews garden leaves, and a mantis eats whatever insects it can catch, pests and beneficial insects alike.

The most common praying mantis lookalikes are mantidflies, thread-legged bugs, ambush bugs, katydids and walking sticks. A true mantis has a triangular head, a long neck-like segment and spiked front legs folded under the head, but no beak. A mantidfly with the same front legs stays under 1 in and has clear, lacewing-like wings.

Lookalike Insect group Grasping front legs Wings as adult Usually found
Thread-legged bug Assassin bug (Emesinae) Yes Winged or wingless Sheds, barns, old spider webs
Ambush bug Assassin bug (Phymatinae) Yes Yes Flowers such as goldenrod
Katydid Tettigoniidae No Yes Shrubs, trees, garden plants
Walking stick Phasmida No No (northern walkingstick) Trees and shrubs
Wheel bug Assassin bug (Reduviidae) Partly, holds prey Yes Garden plants, trees
Mantidfly Mantispidae Yes Yes, clear and veined Porch lights at night
True praying mantis Mantodea Yes, spiked and folded Yes in most adults Gardens, meadows, shrubs

Small and Tiny Bugs That Look Like a Praying Mantis

Small bugs that look like a praying mantis are mostly thread-legged bugs and ambush bugs, two groups of assassin bugs (family Reduviidae). Thread-legged bugs (subfamily Emesinae) have hair-thin legs and a mantis-like front pair. They turn up in sheds, barns and old spider webs, where some species steal prey from the web owner.

Ambush bugs (subfamily Phymatinae) are stocky, yellow and white, and sit still on goldenrod and other flowers. They grab bees and flies that land to feed. Both groups are true bugs with a beak-like mouth folded under the head. A mantis never has a beak.

A baby praying mantis is a tiny lookalike that really is a mantis. It already has the triangular head and raised front legs of an adult, just without wings.

Green Bugs That Look Like a Praying Mantis

Scudderia bush katydid: Green Bugs That Look Like a Praying Mantis
Scudderia bush katydid. Photo: Judy Gallagher, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

A green bug that looks like a praying mantis is most often a katydid (family Tettigoniidae), such as a bush katydid in the genus Scudderia. Katydids have leaf-shaped wings, very long antennae and big hind legs built for jumping.

Green grasshoppers have short antennae and chew on leaves. Their front legs are for walking, not grabbing. The green mantidfly (Zeugomantispa minuta) of the southern US is small and bright green, with mantis forelegs and clear wings.

The fastest clue is behavior. Touch a katydid or grasshopper and it jumps or runs. A mantis sways, turns its head toward you or raises its forelegs. Female praying mantises are green and heavy-bodied, yet they keep the triangular head and folded forelegs that no katydid has.

Brown and Black Bugs That Look Like a Praying Mantis

Brown and black bugs that look like a praying mantis are mostly walking sticks and assassin bugs. The northern walkingstick (Diapheromera femorata) has a twig-shaped body and six legs that all look alike. None of its legs grab, and it moves slowly enough to pass for a branch.

The two-striped walkingstick (Anisomorpha buprestoides) of the Southeast is dark brown to black with pale stripes along its back. It can spray a fluid that burns the eyes, so keep your face away from it.

The wheel bug (Arilus cristatus) is a gray-brown assassin bug with a curved beak tucked under the head. Look for the cog-shaped crest on its back, which gives the bug its name. Do not pick one up. A wheel bug can deliver a painful bite.

Praying mantis eggs cause a third mix-up. They sit inside a brown, papery clump glued to a twig or fence, and that clump is not a bug at all.

Winged Bugs That Look Like a Praying Mantis

A flying bug that looks like a praying mantis is most likely a mantidfly (family Mantispidae). Mantidflies carry mantis-style front legs on a lacewing body, and they are close relatives of lacewings, not mantises. Their wings are clear and veined and rest roof-like over the body. A mantis folds its wings flat along its back.

Snakeflies (order Raphidioptera) look mantis-like for a different reason. They have a long neck and hold the head raised, but their front legs are ordinary walking legs.

Mantidflies come to porch lights at night, just like adult male mantises. Snakeflies in the US live mainly in western states.

How to Tell a True Praying Mantis From a Lookalike

Check the head first. A mantis has a triangular head that turns to follow you, and few insects can look over their shoulder like that.

Check the neck second. The long first body segment, the prothorax, sits between the head and the front legs and looks like a neck. Check the front legs last. They are folded, lined with spines and held up as if praying. The native Carolina mantis (Stagmomantis carolina), the Chinese mantis (Tenodera sinensis) and the European mantis (Mantis religiosa) all pass. A true praying mantis is commonly read as a sign of good luck.

A mantidfly passes the leg check, so its clear, roof-like wings and a body under 1 in decide. Color proves nothing. Mantises come in green, brown, white and pink. The orchid mantis is pink and white, yet it passes all three checks.

Faunalist Tip: Photograph the bug from the side with its front legs in view and upload it to iNaturalist for a community ID. Leave it where it is. A side view shows all three checks.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are praying mantis bugs poisonous?

No. Praying mantises are neither poisonous nor venomous, and their bite carries no toxin. A large mantis can pinch with its spiked forelegs if you grab it, and the pinch can surprise you. Let a mantis walk onto your hand instead of picking it up by the body.

Is a mantidfly a type of praying mantis?

No. Mantidflies belong to the order Neuroptera with lacewings. The larvae of many species ride on spiders and grow up inside spider egg sacs.

Is a walking stick related to a praying mantis?

No. Walking sticks form their own order, Phasmida, and eat only leaves. Praying mantises are closer kin of cockroaches and termites and eat only live prey.

What month does praying mantis lay eggs?

September and October are the main egg-laying months for praying mantises across most of the US. The female glues a foamy egg case to a twig, stem or fence. The eggs inside survive the winter, and the nymphs hatch the following spring once the weather warms up again.




Illustrated portrait of Hannah Whitlock

Written by Hannah Whitlock

Hannah Whitlock writes The Faunalist's coverage of insects, spiders and household pests.

Similar Posts